
Originally Posted by
FireWire79
I have owned all three trucks that you are interested in. I will go into the pros/cons and my personal likes/dislikes for each.
E-Maxx
This was my first hobby quality RC. It has some constant problems. One is that it doesn't handle well. It is prone to rollovers in corners, which results in you having to walk over to it all the time to right it. The bulkheads are prone to breakage in wrecks. This leads to a long disassembly project, and gets very old after doing it three or four times.
As for it's pluses, it is a good basher and has a variety of aftermarket parts available to it. Also, it is waterproof, which is fun while bashing. Mud makes for a good time.
E-Revo/Brushless
The E-Revo was the next one that I got. When comparing it to the E-Maxx, it was like night and day. The speeds were similar, at least stock. The handling was outstanding. It was way more stable in the corners and was able to push itself around like it should have. Also, it was able to be adjusted to be a more than capable basher, and still handled well. Also, it can be converted to run on road by adding a few parts and making some small adjustments.
On the downside, I personally don't care for the battery bays. Nothing against them, but they do unfortunately limit what brands and sizes that you could run.
Once the brushless system was installed the truck was still able to handle everything that I could throw at it, except water that is. It still performed well with the LiPos. I was really very pleased with the E-Revo, from one end to the other. I was really happy being able to reach top speed quickly, and it was achievable both on the track and while bashing.
Summit
I sold my dedicated crawler and my E-Revo to get the Summit. I was anxious to own a truck that did a little bit of everything. To my surprise the Summit has exceeded my expectations. The funny thing about that is, I am prone to pessimism. I had a spot in mind to test it out. Go down the rock slide, across the creek, and back up the other rock slide. After a few attempts and found the right lines, I was able to do it. I was very happy.
On the plus side, for the occasional basher, this is the perfect truck. It handles well off and on road, can crawl, well enough for most people. One other "cool" factor is the built in LEDs and the Exo-Cage. The Exo-Cage provides a lot of additional strength and protection for the body. The LEDs do provide a lot more light that I had expected and again add to the cool factor.
On the downside, again with the battery bays. But, whatever, I guess I'll cope. It is not as fast as I'd like. Don't get me wrong, it is faster than my dedicated crawler was, and certainly more fun. If you want speed, the Summit is for you. Fast enough for most, and it is durable, and can do more than one thing, bash. True, the E-Revo can bash, street race, and compete on the track, but that is not my point.
Overall, I would say that it comes down to where/how you drive your RCs. If you want to go to the track and throw down against the competition, plus get the added perks of versatility, the E-Revo is a very solid machine, and is the only other car that I would consider adding to my collection. The Summit is good for the weekend basher. You can do a little bit of everything, and have fun doing it. Since they are both based on the same chassis, they handle similarly and have cross compatible parts. All in all, please take a little time to consider what I have said and then make a decision. It is your RC after all, you need to cater to your driving style and hobby.
Either way, I hope you have fun and enjoy getting back into the hobby.